1it makes more sense if the GA was designed to destroy antidermis. then its useful: 2-if the BoM goes evil 3-if Teridax takes over the bot and goes evil 4-if the makuta are killed and the Rahkshi run amok. 5-dozens of other cases.
6go to the mainland, get to the Ignika, ask for the armor, then a Mata puts it on. BOOM. no more trouble with superpowered beings.
7It wouldn't make any sense that the GA was designed to destroy Antidermis, otherwise Ignika would have given it to Tahu in Karda Nui.
8Well, it didn't create the armor until Tren Krom sent it a message telling it to do so.
9Still, TK was never supposed to tell Ignika anything.
10And a lot of things in the MU weren't supposed to go horribly wrong. But they did.
1But this might have evolved from the fact that the GB didn't think that their creations would have emotions.
1it makes more sense if the GA was designed to destroy antidermis. then its useful: 2-if the BoM goes evil 3-if Teridax takes over the bot and goes evil 4-if the makuta are killed and the Rahkshi run amok. 5-dozens of other cases.
6go to the mainland, get to the Ignika, ask for the armor, then a Mata puts it on. BOOM. no more trouble with superpowered beings.
7It wouldn't make any sense that the GA was designed to destroy Antidermis, otherwise Ignika would have given it to Tahu in Karda Nui.
8Well, it didn't create the armor until Tren Krom sent it a message telling it to do so.
9Still, TK was never supposed to tell Ignika anything.
10And a lot of things in the MU weren't supposed to go horribly wrong. But they did.
11No, that's not my point. If Ignika was supposed to receive the order/suggestion/permission to create the GA from someone/something, it wouldn't have been from Tren Krom.
1it makes more sense if the GA was designed to destroy antidermis. then its useful: 2-if the BoM goes evil 3-if Teridax takes over the bot and goes evil 4-if the makuta are killed and the Rahkshi run amok. 5-dozens of other cases.
6go to the mainland, get to the Ignika, ask for the armor, then a Mata puts it on. BOOM. no more trouble with superpowered beings.
7It wouldn't make any sense that the GA was designed to destroy Antidermis, otherwise Ignika would have given it to Tahu in Karda Nui.
8Well, it didn't create the armor until Tren Krom sent it a message telling it to do so.
9Still, TK was never supposed to tell Ignika anything.
10And a lot of things in the MU weren't supposed to go horribly wrong. But they did.
11No, that's not my point. If Ignika was supposed to receive the order/suggestion/permission to create the GA from someone/something, it wouldn't have been from Tren Krom.
12And yet, it didn't do what was needed from it until Tren Krom, who was supposed to have been locked up, told it to. So something went wrong somewhere, because the Great Beings couldn't have been depending on this situation.
1Actually, Greg has already told us the solution to this "problem": 
4Hope this puts an end to these discussions.
31a) Wouldn't have done any good. If it could defeat a Makuta, then Teridax would have been defeated as soon as Tahu used it, and he wasn't. It's designed to work on solid antidermis -- kraata -- not gaseous or liquid antidermis.
4Hope this puts an end to these discussions.
1Alright, not to bring up the controversy again (I'm with Hot Pants here though; if bones can do it, so should everyone else), but is the Huna and warhammer official or not? It's not on BS01 yet, but Greg did agree with it, so...
1it makes more sense if the GA was designed to destroy antidermis. then its useful: 2-if the BoM goes evil 3-if Teridax takes over the bot and goes evil 4-if the makuta are killed and the Rahkshi run amok. 5-dozens of other cases.
6go to the mainland, get to the Ignika, ask for the armor, then a Mata puts it on. BOOM. no more trouble with superpowered beings.
7It wouldn't make any sense that the GA was designed to destroy Antidermis, otherwise Ignika would have given it to Tahu in Karda Nui.
8Well, it didn't create the armor until Tren Krom sent it a message telling it to do so.
9Still, TK was never supposed to tell Ignika anything.
10And a lot of things in the MU weren't supposed to go horribly wrong. But they did.
11No, that's not my point. If Ignika was supposed to receive the order/suggestion/permission to create the GA from someone/something, it wouldn't have been from Tren Krom.
12And yet, it didn't do what was needed from it until Tren Krom, who was supposed to have been locked up, told it to. So something went wrong somewhere, because the Great Beings couldn't have been depending on this situation.
13TK didn't factor in the GBs plans after Mata Nui was activated. Therefore, Ignika wasn't supposed to need TK to tell it what to do regarding the GA. So, either someone/something else was created with the specific purpose of telling the Ignika, or Ignika could create the GA when it judged it necessary.
1I sent you a similar message three days ago, but I think it was skipped over so I'm resending it.
21. When Takanuva changed his colors, he looked like he did in 2003 only gray and white and with different weapons?
32. Now that the threat of the Rahkshi is over, did he change his colors back?
43. Did the Toa Nuva's Adaptive Armor change to neutral form after returning to Metru Nui? If not, what did it make them look like?
54. When Tahu left the MU, was he in Mistika form as depicted in the comic and Mata Nui Saga?
65. Does Tahu look exactly as he did in 2001 only with the Golden Armor?
76. What will happen to Umbra now that Mata Nui is the Ignika and Voya Nui will rot into oblivion in three days?
87. In the Mata Nui Saga, Mata Nui knew of the aftermath of the Great Rescue, but only knows of Takanuva as "a strange Toa of Light". Why is this?
98. What will become of the numerous hostile Rahkshi still inside the MU?
109. What became of Lhikan's Noble Hau?
1110. You said that individuals like the Toa Nuva and Ahkmou will separate from their original groups in favor of others in this new society. Which groups are fairly certain to disband or stay together? (The Toa Mahri, the seven Turaga, the Av-Matoran, etc.)
121) Yes 132) For the moment, I am going to have to say no, only because if post-Makuta comics ever get made in the coming year, the artist would be working off the 2008 set or the 2009 set, as he does not have access to the 2003 set. 143) I believe in the comic they were not shown back in their old forms, again, because the artist did not have 2002 sets to work from. 154) Yes -- see #3 for the reason. 165) I guess, I really haven't thought about "exactly" 176) Umbra does not need heat or air to survive, but most likely will emigrate with the rest and seek out wherever the Ignika is being kept. 187) Mata Nui's knowledge of events that took place while he was asleep is hazy at best, in some places. 198) They will leave the MU. 209) Vakama took it and gave it to Jaller at the end of the second movie. 2110) Only time will tell. I am not making these decisions ahead of time, it depends on what makes sense for the characters involved.
225b. What do you mean "exactly"? Tahu said he now looks like the Toa he used to be, but he still had the Adaptive Armor, which he for the most part replaced with the Golden Armor. Is the 01 form with Golden Armor more accurate or is the incorrectly-sized Stars form accurate? 239b. I mean where is the current location and status of the Noble Hau after its placement on Daxia, and Daxia's destruction and current post-Makuta decay? 2411. Will the two dead Glatorian in the MU ever be laid to rest, and are there even corpses left after the destruction of the Core Processor? 2512. In the Spherus Magna Alternate Universe in which the Makuta never rebelled, Mata Nui had but one robotic body when the job required two and still saved the universe. How did he do it? 2613. You have made it perfectly clear that neither the Matoran language nor the Agori language could possibly have any relation with real-world English, and yet in the RoS Chapter featuring said alternate universe, when Tarduk first tells Vezon his name, he thinks he said "Tar, duck .". Why would he think that an Agori name meant two English words that he couldn't possibly know?
275b) Can I ask why it matters? 289Unknown at present 2911) I doubt it, on both. 3012) How do you know there wasn't a second robot somewhere? Did we say there wasn't? 3113) You're being too literal, TK. It's a story. It has humor in it. You don't need to be parsing it to this point.
1Tren Krom (and everyone else) about Question #12, on the Alternate Universe, there was no Mata Nui, and it was the Toa (Matoran) who fixed the planet before it shattered. It's on Brothers in Arms final chapters.
1Tren Krom (and everyone else) about Question #12, on the Alternate Universe, there was no Mata Nui, and it was the Toa (Matoran) who fixed the planet before it shattered. It's on Brothers in Arms final chapters.
2You're reffering to the 'Melding' universe, there was also another alternate universe where the Makuta never rebelled. 3You could read that one in Reign of Shadows.
4It was one of the universes that Vezon past through.11) Did Tuyet wear a powerless version of her Mask of Intangibility as a Matoran? 22) Did Nidihiki wear a powerless version of his Volitak as a Matoran? 35) When Gorast, Krika, and Bitil were exposed to the Pit Mutagen, were their masks also mutated? 46) Does the Tryna use a tiny portion of its user's life-force to animate bodies? 57) Did Savage wear a Ruru as a Toa? I ask this because his set has a Hordika Ruru piece as his head. Same question for Prototype. 68) I know you said the Kanohi of Elemental Energy would not appear in the story, even though it's canon. I was wondering, though: why don't you want it in the story? 79) Would the Adaptive Aki and Adaptive Rua assume the respective shapes of the Adaptive Hau and Adaptive Miru in their various environments? 810) Does Vican still wear his powerless Mask of Silence? 911) Can you confirm that 'Mask of Light and Shadow' is/was the title for Takutanuva's mask?
101-2) Yes 115) No. They had already assumed those shapes, the mutagen just locked them into them. 126) No 137) Not something I have thought about 148) Because it's a video power-up, and that is all it was ever intended to be. 159) Irrelevant, since Akamai and Wairuha won't be reappearing in story 1610) Yes 1711) That's what I call it. It only existed for a couple minutes, so I doubt it ever got formally named in the BIONICLE universe.
1Thank you so much for answering me. I have I a few more questions for you.
21) Now that Spherus Magna is reformed and the "three have become one", does Spherus Magna have the celestial arms of the three virtues symbol or were those pulled and made part of Spherus Magna?
32) Have we seen the last of the Vahi, or will it come back later in the plot?
43) Now that the Golden Armor perpose has been served will Tahu continue to where it?
54) Was Spherus Magna reformed into a true sphere, or does it really look like the squashed play-dough ball shown in the comic?
61) No, they are still out there, but most likely disrupted by the passage of the moons through them. 72) No idea. 83) Personally, I tend to doubt it. 94) It would be hard for it to be an actual sphere, because fragments of the moons came off during their passage back to BM.
11. Why did Tahu's Hau Nuva change into a regular Hau, not the Golden Hau he was wearing when he was transformed into a Toa Nuva?
2-TN05
3Because the Ignika was rolling back his evolution, and his natural form before the Nuva was with the original Hau, which he had been wearing for 100,000 years. He only wore the gold Hau for a very short time. And from a practical standpoint, I didn't want him wearing a mask that had six powers in it.
4-TN05
1No, it doesn't. But it doesn't make you a normal member (under categories, that is
2Anways, people, I have one thing to say after all this - Instances like this are okay, but you should certainly NOT flood Greg's inbox about canonizing.
3-GRESHIOS
4I suppose you're right. I just think that we should hold polls for things like this. We have in the past and it worked fine, so why stop now?
5
6that is a good idea
1Hey GregF, just a couple of questions. 21. Was the Dweller in the Deep created by the Makuta or was it one of the First Rahi created by the Great Beings? 32. Should we base colors of Toa of Sonics off of Krakua? 43. Do all Toa Team names have a meaning, including ones we have never heard of, or could it be just a random name, random like Lhikan or John or etc.?
51) It was created by Makuta. 62) <Shrug> The person who built Krakua had to use existing pieces, so the prospect of using new colors was not a possibility. If you are okay with his colors, use them as a basis. 73) Toa are normally named after the region they are guarding.
1@preston stormer: In case you didn't know, Lewa Krom said that it should be best if these contests are left for the BZP and BS01 staff.
1Hi, not much.
21. Does tahu still WEAR the golden armor, for symbolical reasons, or is it stored safe somewhere?
32. Just to clarify, is the "one of the brutish race that served as laborers on Stelt." from ROS 10, that formed the golden super kaita, one of Krekka's species or something else.
4And
53. does the Red Star ACTUALLY form predictions in the constellations, or is this just matoran superstition. 6a. if so, does it continue to do so?
7Thanks.
81) I don't see him continuing to wear it, no 92) Krekka's 103) I see it as Matoran superstition.
11I can't believe I just communicated with the legendary Greg Farshety
1Oh come on guys. It's just a weapon and a mask. This isn't life-changing. It's just a simple canonization. Move on.
2-GRESHIOS
3You can ask them all you want...they wont stop getting off topic. This is the "OGD", not the "Lets argue about canonizing things-forum", I dont know why they dont make a seperate topic all about that...seriously has anyone thought of that? Itll get to the point where no one is allowed to post in here without permission.
1Oh come on guys. It's just a weapon and a mask. This isn't life-changing. It's just a simple canonization. Move on.
2-GRESHIOS
3You can ask them all you want...they wont stop getting off topic. This is the "OGD", not the "Lets argue about canonizing things-forum", I dont know why they dont make a seperate topic all about that...seriously has anyone thought of that? Itll get to the point where no one is allowed to post in here without permission.
4Strictly speaking this is the topic for stuff like that. You want just facts go to the Farshtey Feed
1Oh come on guys. It's just a weapon and a mask. This isn't life-changing. It's just a simple canonization. Move on.
2-GRESHIOS
3You can ask them all you want...they wont stop getting off topic. This is the "OGD", not the "Lets argue about canonizing things-forum", I dont know why they dont make a seperate topic all about that...seriously has anyone thought of that? Itll get to the point where no one is allowed to post in here without permission.
4Strictly speaking this is the topic for stuff like that. You want just facts go to the Farshtey Feed
5True...it just gets rediculous in here sometimes
6Im just agreeing with greshios on the fact that they need to move on. The worlds not gonna end if something isnt canonized.1Hi Greg, I just have one question about the Graphic Novels by Papercutz.
28 and 10 will have new content, I believe. Will the Journey's End comics be included in GN 9: The Fall of Atero?
3Thank you very much, have a nice day.
4BFN
5#9 is 2009 comics, not 2010. And at this point, there is still no word on whether #10 will ever come out. I have not been asked to do more work on it.
6Sad stuff.
1I was sort of hoping there was some meaning to the Red Star's predictions.......
1All the more reason to buy #8 and #9 to get #10.
1Hey Greg, as you may know, some of us are trying to get permission from Lego for this guy who has The Legend of Mata Nui beta disk to give it to us. I asked them through the customer service center on Lego, and(even though they said they don't have the game any more and the company is no longer interested in it) the the person who sent me back an e-mail said "we would not be able to grant permission of this". Do you think this is because he doesn't have the authority, or some other reason?
1Hey Greg, as you may know, some of us are trying to get permission from Lego for this guy who has The Legend of Mata Nui beta disk to give it to us. I asked them through the customer service center on Lego, and(even though they said they don't have the game any more and the company is no longer interested in it) the the person who sent me back an e-mail said "we would not be able to grant permission of this". Do you think this is because he doesn't have the authority, or some other reason?
2Greg rarely visits this topic. You have to send him a PM with your questions and wait for him to answer. Then post your dialogue in this topic once he replies
. 3-TNTOS-
1Thanks TNTOS
1Everyone here needs to relax, he got something canonized, we should be thanking him for adding 2 more small details to BS01. I think the reason people here are upset it because "why couldn't I get my idea made canon, and why could he?" Everyone needs to act more mature, it's not a contest or a competition over who can get things canonized
1Actually, it's not on BS01 for some reason.
1They're probably waiting for us to finish so they can determine whether it's canon or not.
1Actually, they removed it because they didn't like how it was canonized. Apparently they didn't consider it true info.
1But they canonized it when Bonesii created 11 new masks alone. Why is that different?
1Actually, they removed it because they didn't like how it was canonized. Apparently they didn't consider it true info.
2That's actually a lie.
3From what I gather, Lewa Krom actually tried to recall said info from GregF. We are still trying to determine if it's something to be considered canon or not.
1You know if Greg likes it, what's the problem? He could have just decided it himself. Usually he wouldn't just canonize something at one request, but obviusly he was in a really good mood that day. It's Greg's call to make and he made it.
1Actually, they removed it because they didn't like how it was canonized. Apparently they didn't consider it true info.
2That's actually a lie.
3From what I gather, Lewa Krom actually tried to recall said info from GregF. We are still trying to determine if it's something to be considered canon or not.
4You removed the info before LK tried to recall the info from GregF.